• View enhanced case on Westlaw
  • KeyCite this case on Westlaw
  • http://laws.findlaw.com/us/196/99.html
    Cases citing this case: Supreme Court
    Cases citing this case: Circuit Courts
    COMSTOCK v. EAGLETON, 196 U.S. 99 (1905)

    U.S. Supreme Court

    COMSTOCK v. EAGLETON, 196 U.S. 99 (1905)

    196 U.S. 99

    J. O. COMSTOCK, Appt.,
    v.
    WILLIAM L. EAGLETON.
    No. 105.

    Submitted December 15, 1904.
    Decided January 3, 1905.

    Messrs. Andrew Wilson, Noel W. Barksdale, C. J. Wrightsman, and E. L. Fulton for appellant.

    No counsel opposed.

    THE CHIEF JUSTICE:

    This was an action brought by Comstock against Eagleton in the district court of Pawnee county, Oklahoma, to recover damages for false imprisonment in the sum of $5,317.50.

    The petition was demurred to on the ground that it did not state facts sufficient to constitute a cause of action, the demurrer sustained, and the petition dismissed with costs. The case was then carried to the supreme court of Oklahoma on error, and the judgment affirmed. 11 Okla. 487, 69 Pac. 955.

    From the judgment of affirmance this appeal was allowed and prosecuted to this court.

    By 9 of the 'Act to Provide a Temporary Government for the Territory of Oklahoma,' approved May 2, 1890 (26 Stat. at L. 81, chap. 182 ), it was provided that 'where the value of the property or the amount in controversy' exceeded $5,000, 'writs of error and appeals from the final decisions of said supreme court shall be allowed and may be [196 U.S. 99, 100]   taken to the Supreme Court of the United States in the same manner and under the same regulations as from the circuit courts of the United States.'

    Final judgments of the circuit courts of the United States in actions at law can only be revised on writs of error. Deland v. Platte County, 155 U.S. 221 , 39 L. ed. 128, 15 Sup. Ct. Rep. 82; Metropolitan R. Co. v. District of Columbia, 195 U.S. 322 , ante, p. 28, 25 Sup. Ct. Rep. 28; Bevins v. Ramsey, 11 How. 185, 13 L. ed. 657; Sarchet v. United States, 12 Pet. 143, 9 L. ed. 1033

    Appeal dismissed.

    FindLaw Career Center

      Search for Law Jobs:

        Post a Job  |  View More Jobs
    Ads by FindLaw