Court of Appeals Opinions 1999

Dec. 30, 1999

Reinninger v. Prestige Fabricators Inc. reinninger  
First Union v. Ingold, et al first_union  
Bookholt v. Bookholt bookholt  
State v. Stevenson stevenson  
State v. Fusco fusco  

Dec. 21, 1999

Bio-Medical v. Human Resources biomedical  
Scurlock v. Durham Co. General Hospital scurlock  
Twaddell v. Anderson twaddell  
Staton, et al v. Brame staton  
Lexington Ins. v. Tires Into Recycled lexington  
Hixson v. Krebs hixson  
Tucker, et al v. Westlake tucker  
State v. Garner garner  
State v. Brooks brooks  
McClure v. Reynolds Co. mcclure  
Benton, et al v. Hillcrest Foods, et al benton  
State v. Broome broome  
State v. Williams williams  
Harry v. Crescent Resources Inc. harry1  
Looking Glass v. City of Charlotte, BOA looking_glass  
Latimer v. Latimer latimer  
Harry v. Mecklenburg County, et al harry2  
State v. Spinks spinks  
State, ex rel Desselberg v. Peele desselberg  
Arquilla, et al v. City of Salisbury arquilla  
Richardson, et al v. Union County BOA richardson  
Winborne v. Easley, et al winborne  
State v. Hughes hughes  

Dec. 7, 1999

State v. Bowers bowers  
McGinnis Point Owners v. Joyner, et al mcginnis  
State v. Blackwell blackwell  
State v. Roberts roberts  
Wrenn v. Maria Parham Hospital wrenn  
City of Durham v. Hicks, et al durham  
Iodice v. Jones iodice  
Clayton v. Burnett, et al clayton  
Tew v. Brown tew  
Matthews v. Food Lion matthews  
Collins v. Talley, et al collins  
Mann Contractors v. Flair With Goldsmith mann  
Keistler v. Keistler keistler  
Wolfe v. Wilmington Shipyard wolfe  
State v. Smith l_smith  
Rowan County DSS & Brooks v. Brooks brooks  
Brannock v. Brannock brannock  
State v. Linemann linemann  
Milligan v. State of N.C., et al milligan  
Myers v. Town of Plymouth myers  

Nov. 16, 1999

Burke Health Investors v. NCDHR burke  
State v. Mitchell mitchell  
Brinkley (Harvey) v. Brinkley brinkley  
State v. Chisholm chisholm  
Darby v. Darby darby  
Bates v. Jarrett, et al bates  
State v. Gilley gilley  
Alexander v. Quattlebaum, et al alexander  
Nunnery v. Baucom nunnery  
Roberts v. Swain roberts  
Sitton v. Cole sitton  
Department of Correction v. McNeely ncdoc  
State v. Perez perez  
Comer v. Ammons, et al comer  
Trexler v. Pollock, et al trexler  

Nov. 2, 1999

State v. Shuler shuler  
In the matter of Nicholas Jones jones  
Village Creek Prop. v. Edenton, et al village_creek  
State v. Owens owens  
Tomika Inv. v. Macedonia True Vine Ch. tomika  
Andrews v. Carr, et al f_andrews  
In the matter of Tamara B. McLean mclean  
Rush v. Living Centers-Southeast rush  
Hill v. Lassiter hill  
State v. Welch welch  
State v. Wilson wilson  
Gaunt, et al v. Pittaway, et al gaunt  
Marley v. Graper marley  
State of N.Y./Andrews v. Paugh k_andrews  
Hobbs v. N.C. DHR, et al hobbs  
Roten v. Critcher roten  
Lane v. R.N. Rouse & Co. lane  
Tevepaugh v. Tevepaugh tevepaugh  

Oct. 19, 1999

McGee v. N.C. Department of Revenue mcgee  
Ruggery v. N.C. DOC ruggery  
Moore v. City of Raleigh moore  
Rivera v. Trapp rivera  
In re: Southeastern Baptist Seminary baptist  
Osburn, et al v. Danek Medical, Inc. osburn  
Parchment v. Garner, et al parchment  
Norris v. Zambito, et al norris  
State v. Bright bright  
Napier v. Napier napier  
In the Matter: Krantz krantz  
Wilburn v. Honeycutt wilburn  
Coiner v. Cales coiner  
Penland, et al v. Harris penland  
In Re: Espinosa v. Martin, et al espinosa  
State v. Smith smith  
In the Matter of: Ellis ellis  
State v. Marine marine  
Franzen v. Franzen franzen  
K&S Enterprises v. Kennedy Office Supply kennedy  
Canoy v. Canoy canoy  
State v. White white  

Oct. 5, 1999

Horton, et al v. Powell Plumbing & Heat horton  
Collins, et al v. Horizon Housing Inc. collins  
Rissolo v. Sloop, DDS rissolo  
Blackmon v. Bumgardner, et al blackmon  
Market America Inc. v. Christman-Orth marketamerica  
State v. Graves graves  
Sanders v. American Spirit Insurance sanders  
The Country Club v. U.S. Fidelity countryclub  
State v. Parisi parisi  
Von Pettis Realty v. McKoy vonpettis  
Cooper v. BOE for Nash-Rocky Mt. Schools cooper  
G.E. Capital Mortgage v. Neely, et al ge  
State v. Leggett leggett  

Sept. 21, 1999

Frazier v. Murray, et al frazier  
Calderwood v. The Charlotte-Mecklenburg calderwood  
Davis v. Embree-Reed, Inc., et al davis  
Bowen v. NC DHHS bowen  
Deerman v. Beverly California Corp. deerman  
Allstate Ins. v. Chatterton, et al allstate  
State v. Gentry gentry  
Nolan v. Paramount Homes Inc., et al nolan  
In Re: Estate of Maggie F. Ferguson ferguson  
Hiwassee Stables v. Cunningham, et al hiwassee  
State v. Clapp clapp  
State v. Dorsey dorsey  
Dalton, et al v. Camp, et al dalton  
Bailey, et al v. Gitt, et al bailey  
In Re: Leftwich & Ayers leftwich  
State v. Lundy & Evans lundy  
State v. Trogden trogden  
Bledsoe v. County of Wilkens, et al bledsoe  
State v. Crumbley crumbley  
Hudson v. Hudson hudson  

Sept. 7, 1999

De Portillo v. D.H. Griffin Wrecking Co. valles  
Toler v. Black and Decker toler  
Wright v. Blue Ridge Area wright  
Fire Baptized Holiness v. McSwain fire_baptized  
State v. Stanfield stanfield  
Chance v. Henderson chance  
Karner, et al v. Roy White Flowers Inc. karner  
Hieb, et al v. Lowery hieb  
Anderson v. Atlantic Casualty Ins. anderson  
Rogers v. Sportsworld, T.J.O. Inc. rogers  
Inman v. Inman inman  
Reese, et al v. Barbee reese  
State v. Teague teague  

Aug. 17, 1999

State v. Coble coble  
Wilson v. Wilson wilson  
Jones v. Asheville Radiological jones  
Rhoney v. Fele, et al rhoney  
Thomas v. Thomas s_thomas  
McIver v. Smith mciver  
State v. Branch branch  
State v. Holston holston  
State v. Burgess burgess  
Fulton v. Mickle fulton  
Bueltel v. Lumber Mutual Insurance bueltel  
State v. Thomas j_thomas  
State v. Chavis chavis  
State v. Underwood underwood  

Aug. 3, 1999

Barber v. Going West Transportation barber  
Flores v. Penny Masonry Company flores  
Jenkins v. Public Service Company jenkins  
Lewis v. Craven Regional Medical lewis  
Perkins v. Arkansas Trucking Services perkins  
In the Matter of: Phoenix Limited phoenix  
Sain-Crosby v. Sain sain-crosby  
Howze v. Hughes, et al howze  
State v. Pretty pretty  
Holshouser v. Shaner Hotel Group holshouser  
Little v. Hamel, et al little  

July 20, 1999

Jarvis v. Food Lion Inc. jarvis  
Bali Co., et al v. City of Kings Mountain bali  
Riviere v. Riviere riviere  
In the Matter of: K.R.B krb  
Johnson v. York, et al johnson  
Staley v. York, et al staley  
Market America Ind. v. Christman-Orth market_america  
Schmidt v. Breeden, et al schmidt  
South Mecklenburg Painting v. The Cunnane Group south_mecklenburg  
Crowder Construction v. Kiser crowder  
Adams v. Samuels, et al adams  
N.C. Farm Bureau Mutual v. Weaver farmbureau  
Alvarez v. Alvarez alvarez  
Barnett v. King barnett  
State v. Grigsby grigsby  
Shell Island Homeowners v. Tomlinson shell_island1  
Shell Island Homeowners v. Tomlinson shell_island2  
State v. Coastland Corp. coastland1  
Coastland Corp. v. N.C. Wildlife Resources coastland2  
Crump, et al v. Snead crump  
Winston v. Brodie, et al winston  
State v. White white  
Key v. Burchette, et al key  

July 6, 1999

Lanning v. Fieldcrest-Cannon Inc. lanning  
Smith v. Champion International b_smith  
Sweet, et al v. Boggs sweet  
Freeman v. Sugar Mountain Resort freeman  
Aycock v. Padgett, et al aycock  
Concrete Machinery v. City of Hickory concrete  
Brisson v. Santoriello brisson  
State v. Earhart earhart  
Akins, et al v. City of Thomasville akins  
Duke University Medical v. Bruton duke  
Bogan v. Bogan bogan  
Howard v. Oakwood Homes Corp. howard  
CBP Resources Inc. v. Mountaire Farms cbp  
Huskins v. Huskins huskins  
Hieb, et al v. Lowery hieb  
Lorinovich, et al v. Kmart Corp. lorinovich  
Fran's Pecans Inc. v. Greene, et al fran's  
State v. Pierce pierce  
State v. Smith r_smith  
Buckingham v. Buckingham buckingham  
In the Matter of: Declaratory Ruling by N.C. Commissioner of Insurance insurance  
Jones v. Winckelmann, et al jones  
Schnitzlein v. Hardee's Food Systems schnitzlein  
In the Matter of: Crawford crawford  

June 15, 1999

Williams v. ARL Inc. williams  
Coppley v. PPG Industries Inc. coppley  
Walker v. Branch Banking & Trust walker  
State v. Owen owen  
State v. Campbell campbell  
Atlantic Veneer v. Robbins atlantic  
State v. Rankins rankins  
In the Matter of the Estate of Hodgin hodgin  
Energy Investors v. Metric Constructors energy  
State v. Anthony anthony  
State v. Howard and Lee howard  
State v. Jones jones  
Hoisington v. ZT-Winston-Salem, et al hoisington  
State v. Harkness harkness  
Perkins v. Helms & Hartford Casualty perkins  
State v. Little little  
State v. Bass bass  
Patterson v. Strickland patterson  
Webb, et al v. Nash Hospitals Inc. webb  
State v. Cardwell cardwell  
Camp, et al v. Leonard, et al camp  
Faulkenbury, et al v. Teachers, et al faulkenbury  
Telesca v. SAS Institute telesca  

June 1, 1999

Hauser, et al v. Advanced Plastiform hauser  
Hutelmyer v. Cox hutelmyer  
Robinson v. Leach robinson  
In the matter of: Shannon M. McDonald mcdonald  
Lovelace v. City of Shelby lovelace  
Price v. Price price  
State v. Nesbitt nesbitt  
Southern Furniture Co. v. DOT southern  
JWL Investments v. Guilford Co. Bd. jwl  
Tyson v. Henry, et al tyson  
Shore v. Farmer shore  
Cauble v. Cauble cauble  

May 18, 1999

Deese v. Champion Int'l, et al deese  
Mittendorff v. Mittendorff mittendorff  
State v. Foreman foreman  
State v. Ross ross  
Green Tree Financial v. Young, et al greentree  
State v. Wilds wilds  
Monson v. Paramont Homes Inc. monson  
Buchanan v. Hight, et al buchanan  
Ausley v. Bishop ausley  
State v. Jarrell jarrell  
Burnett v. Wheeler burnett  
Brooker v. Brooker brooker  
Massengill v. Duke University massengill  
Cox v. Cox cox1  
Cox v. Cox cox2  
Midulla, et al v. Howard A. Cain Inc. miulla  
Hardy v. Moore County, et al hardy  
Young v. Young young  
Polygenex International v. Polyzen Inc. polygenex  
In the matter of: T.S. ts  
State v. Williams williams  
Lilley, et al v. Blue Ridge Electric lilley  
Mastin v. Griffith, et al mastin  

May 4, 1999

Stafford v. Stafford stafford  
Anderson v. Town of Andrews, et al anderson  
Parkwood Association v. Capital Health parkwood  
Couch, et al v. Private Diagnostic Clinic couch  
Replacements Ltd. v. Midwesterling replacements  
Swan Quarter Farms Inc. v. Spencer swanquarter  
Sale Chevrolet v. Peterbilt of Florence sale  
Mehovic v. Mehovic, et al mehovic  
First Citizens v. 4325 Park Road Assoc. first-citizens  
Davies, et al v. Lewis, et al davies  
Laing v. Lewis laing  
Martin v. Vance, et al martin  
Procter v. City of Raleigh, BOA procter  
Coleman v. Hines, et al coleman  
Sharp v. Sharp, et al sharp  

April 20, 1999

Choate v. Sara Lee Products choate  
Robinson v. East Carolina University robinson  
Sweat v. Brunswick Electric sweat  
City of Asheville v. Morris, et al asheville  
In the Matter Of: Natasha Everette everette  
Strickland v. State Farm Mutual Auto strickland  
Streeter v. Cotton streeter  
Alston v. Duke University, et al alston  
Iodice, et al v. Jones iodice  
Talley v. Talley talley  
Brown v. Roth, et al brown  
Spencer v. Spencer spencer  
State v. Penuel, et al penuel  
State v. Blackwell blackwell  
Daniels,et al v. Reel, et al daniels  

April 6, 1999

Davis v. Weyerhaeuser Co. davis  
Peeler v. Piedmont Elastic Inc. peeler  
State of N.C., ex rel Utilities Comm. v. MCI, et al utilities  
Andrews v. Alamance County, et al andrews  
State v/ Reaves reaves  
State v. Hyatt hyatt  
Dillingham v. N.C. DHR dillingham  
State v. Summers summers  
Falk Integrated Technologies v. Stack falk  
Wiggins v. Pelikan Inc. wiggins  
Teleflex Information v. Arnold teleflex  
Romig v. Jefferson-Pilot Life romig  
State v. Moore moore  
State v. Cintron cintron  
Middleton v. The Russell Group, et al middleton  
Rice v. Danas Inc. rice  
State v. Phillips phillips  
Vogl v. LVD Cprp. et al vogl  
Haight, et al v. Travelers/Aetna haight  
State v. Woody woody  
Centura Bank v. Executive Leather Inc. centura  
Brandon v. Brandon brandon  
State v. Adams adams  
Gibbons, et al v. Cole, et al gibbons  
Union Carbide Corp. v. Offerman union_carbide  
Williams v. 100 Block Associates williams  
State, Long v. ILA Corp. long  
Webb v. McKeel webb  
Holcomb v. Holcomb holcomb  
Seigel v. Patel, et al seigel  

March 16, 1999

Dishmond v. International Paper dishmond  
City-Wide Asphalt Paving v. Alamance Co. citywide  
C.C.&J. Enterprises v. City of Asheville cc&j  
Cloer v. Smith cloer  
Lang v. Lang lang  
Ridenhour v. IBM ridenhour  
Price v. Davis, et al price  
Avant v. Sandhills Center avant  

March 2, 1999

Lowery v. Locklear Construction lowery  
Bartell v. Sawyer, et al bartell  
Floyd v. First Citizens Bank floyd  
Foster v. Carolina Marble & Tile Co. foster  
Davis, et al v. City of Mebane davis  
Robertson v. Hunsinger robertson  
Robinson v. Entwistle, et al robinson  
State v. Minor minor  
State v. Thomas thomas  
State v. Petty petty  
State v. Rich rich  
Whiteco Outdoor v. Johnston Co. whiteco  
Fortune Ins. Co. v. Owens, et al fortune  
Van Dorn Retail v. Klaussner Furniture van_dorn  
Nationwide Mutual v. Webb nationwide  
Wells v. Wells wells  
Barnard, et al v. Rowland, et al barnard  
Poe v. Atlas Soundolier/American Trading poe  
American Continental v. Phico Ins. american  

February 16, 1999

Timmons v. N.C. DOT timmons  
In the Matter of: C.D. Owens, et al owens  
In the Matter of: Sterling Diagnostic sterling  
Horner, Executrix v. Byrnett horner  
State v. McCaslin mccaslin  
Whitley v. Kennerly, et al whitley  
State v. Fritsch, et al fritsch  
Hicks, et al v. Clegg's Termite hicks  
Watson v. Dixon & Duke Univ. watson  
Few, et al v. Hammack Enterprises few  
Transcontinental Gas v. Calco Enterprises transcontinental  
State v. Monk monk  
State v. Gartlan gartlan  
In re: Atasha D. Bean in_re_bean  
Vanasek v. Duke Power vanasek  
In the Matter of: Emmanuel Molina molina  
Lewis v. Jones, et al lewis  
Hudson-Cole Development v. Beemer hudson-cole  
State v. McAllister mcallister  
State v. Hamilton hamilton  
Huang v. Ziko, et al huang  
O'Carroll v. Texasgulf Inc. ocarroll  
sutton v. n.c> Department of Labor sutton  
Daughtry v. McLamb, et al daughtry  

February 2, 1999

Pittman v. International Paper Co. pittman  
Riggins v. Elkay Southern Corp. riggins  
Crutchfield v. Crutchfield crutchfield  
State v. Bennett bennett  
State v. Britt britt  
Sharp v. Gailor, et al sharp  
American Manuf. v. Hagler, et al american  
Sharpe v. Worland sharpe  
State v. Byrd byrd  
Delta Environmental v. Wynsong & Miles delta  
Trosch v. State Farm Automobile trosch  
Hart, et al v. F.N. Thompson Constr. hart  
State v. Hill hill  
State v. Moore moore  
Beechridge Development v. Dahners beechridge  
Daniel v. Daniel daniel  
Faulkenbury v. State Retirement faulkenbury  

January 19, 1999

Fulcher v. Willard's Cab. Co. fulcher  
The N.C. State Bar v. Barrett, Attorney ncbar  
First Union National v. Lindley Lab firstunion  
In the matter of: Robinson robinson  
Gray, et al v. N.C. Insurance Underwriting gray  
Wheeler, et al v. Queen wheeler  
Atkinson v. Atkinson atkinson  
Hearndon v. Hearndon hearndon  
Barrett v. N.C. Psychology Board barrett  
Seipp v. Wake Bd. of Education seipp  
Harvell v. N.C. Association of Educators harvell  
Spruill v. Lake Phelps Vol. Fire Dept. spruill  

January 5, 1999

Evans v. Cowan evans  
Heath v. Heath heath  
Kenan v. Bass kenan  
Matthews v. Charlotte-Mecklenburg Hospital Auth. matthews  
Melvin v. St. Louis melvin  
State v. Gary gary  
State v. Schiffer schiffer